Povidone iodine | Chlorhexidine acetate | PHMB | ||||
Early apoptosis | Late apoptosis | Early apoptosis | Late apoptosis | Early apoptosis | Late apoptosis | |
(A) | ||||||
1/512 | 4.34±0.36 | 93.83±1.86 | 0.78±0.57 | 13.93±2.06 | 1.71±0.73 | 13.90±2.98 |
1/64 | – | – | 1.54±0.36 | 15.93±2.96 | 1.03±0.32 | 15.83±2.12 |
1/8 | – | – | 1.69±0.23 | 74.80±2.56* | 8.69±2.05* | 81.43±3.39* |
(B) | ||||||
1/512 | 0.16±0.07 | 99.43±0.35 | 0.96±0.35 | 8.78±0.17 | 4.08±0.45 | 10.39±1.06 |
1/64 | – | – | 2.62±0.89* | 20.90±2.15* | 3.48±0.54 | 20.17±5.70* |
1/8 | – | – | 2.22±0.20 | 86.77±5.49* | 2.15±0.16 | 87.50±3.17* |
*Statistically significant difference compared with previous dilution; p<0.05.
–, unable to detect; HF, human fibroblasts; PHMB, polyhexamethylene biguanide.